Verdi’s ‘Don Carlo’ works its magic at the ROH

 Verdi’s Don Carlo, based on the play Don Carlos by the German dramatist Schiller, is an intensely human drama. Its background is the Spanish Court during the reign of Philip II, son of the

Emperor Charles V. This is the same Philip who was co-ruler of England after his marriage to Mary I, daughter of Henry VIII, until her death nearly three years later (their twin portraits

even featured on coins of the time). Historically, Don Carlos was Philip’s son and heir to the throne, by most accounts a brutal and rather nasty young man who died in 1568 at the age of 23.

Don’t let any of that spoil a good story however, and Schiller’s drama is very good indeed. So too is Verdi’s opera, first produced for Paris in 1867, and later that year in London. The

present production at Covent Garden is the five-act 1886 Italian version (Don Carlo), where in Act 1, Carlos meets his betrothed Elisabeth de Valois, before she becomes his father’s third

wife. She too died in 1568, also aged 23, less than three months after Carlos.

The drama involves a love match between Carlos and Elisabeth, and although many of the court were delighted to see the end of him, Elisabeth apparently was not. She wept for two days.

However, as Sarah Lenton writes in an excellent programme essay, there is no historical evidence that tenderer feelings were involved. Of course, two people of the same age would be

naturally drawn to one another in the bleak court of a king who was happy to be on his own, and in the Escorial their bodies are laid side by side.

Verdi’s opera brings in the vital business of religion. The high command of Spanish Catholicism regarded the Protestants in The Netherlands as heretics, to be brutally subjugated to Spanish

rule. At an auto-da-fé in Act 3 Carlos brings in a group of Flemish envoys to plead with the king for justice, and even draws his sword against his father, before being gently disarmed by

his close friend Rodrigo, the Marquis of Posa. The personal relationships include the beautiful Princess Eboli, who is jealous of Carlos’s affections for the Queen (Elisabeth), and threatens

to unmask him — though she herself is the king’s lover. Heretics, love intrigues, and of course the Grand Inquisitor, who orders the murder of Rodrigo — a wonderful coup de theâtre — and

plays a decisive role at the end in putting down an insurrection against the king.

Powerful stuff indeed, and undoubtedly one of Verdi’s finest operas. The Royal Opera production by Nicholas Hytner is excellent, and musically this worked beautifully under the baton of

Bertrand de Billy. Perfection in singing fell short in some respects. Lisa Davidson as Elisabeth was outstanding, floating lovely soft notes of enduring power. One could hardly do better,

and John Relyea was magnificent as Philip II, outsinging the Grand Inquisitor of Ukrainian bass Taras Shtonda, whose vocal gravitas should be gripping, but wasn’t.

It begins with Elisabeth meeting Don Carlos, sung rather too loudly at the start by Brian Jagde before settling into the role later. Partly for this reason the performance didn’t really gel

until the Romanian bass Alexander Köpecz came on as the ghost of Charles V, appearing later at the very end. A small role, but he was terrific, and the voice from heaven of Sarah Dufresne

was lovely. Although Luca Micheletti sang well in the far more substantial role of Rodrigo, he didn’t entirely convince, though the Eboli of Russian mezzo Yulia Matochkina gave a good

account of this difficult role.

But my goodness this is a well-judged production of one of Verdi’s greatest operas. The House was full to the rafters, and roared its applause.

By proceeding, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and our Privacy Policy.

If an account exists for this email address, you will shortly receive an email from us. You will then need to:

Please note, this link will only be valid for 24 hours. If you do not receive our email, please check your Junk Mail folder and add [email protected] to your safe list.